Are you worried about your children forgetting what they’ve learned all year during the summer?

Studies over the last few years have suggested that summer learning loss is a problem for students compared with their peers in year-round schooling.  Education researchers agree that a shorter break is better for learning.

Advocates claim that year-round calendars help students achieve higher and allow teachers to provide more effective education.   At the same time, other research has shown that year-round schooling does not increase scholastic achievement.

Cary Heise of StayatHomeRockStar.com and her family live outside Raleigh, North Carolina.  Their area leads the state in population growth, expanding near 50% in one year. Their community is bursting young families and their year round school calendar allows 25% more students to use facilities.

“Our family loves to travel! We get breaks during all the seasons, which means we can travel any time of the year.  Families benefit from travel savings when touring places like Disney at off-peak times,” says Heise.

For Heise, their school calendar is made up of four “tracks” – there are three tracks in school at all times.   The only exception is the week of July 4th when all students are “tracked out”, meaning all on vacation at the same time.  So for example, a track might begin mid-July and run for six weeks, out of school for three, back to school for nine weeks, out for three, in for six and so on.

This all-year school calendar works for Heise and her children.  “I love having my kids around (mostly), after they are in school for six weeks, I miss them!  They track out, we have a big old time for three weeks; traveling, visiting museums or just taking some down time.  Then, when the fun has worn out, time to get back to school!”

In Canada, year-round education is more common in Alberta, where there are more than 20 schools offering that option in Calgary alone. But in most other provinces, a two-month summer vacation is the norm. Ontario has a handful of year-long programs.

A year-round school year features the same number of days and curriculum as regular Ontario schools, but almost half of the two-month summer vacation time on the traditional school calendar is spread throughout the year.

But does year-round school really help children retain the information they’ve learned? How is learning affected by the three-week breaks, four times a year?  Does year-round schooling really help learning?

“The only challenge I find with year round school is that matching up family vacations with extended family who are on traditional school schedules,” said Heise.  “It can also be difficult trying to meet up with friends that are local with everyone on different tracks.  Even a neighborhood will have children on all different tracks.”

For others, challenges might come for finding programs or daycare to fill in the gaps.

With pros and cons for each year round education, here is a list of them to help you decide for yourself:

Do kids do better in year-round school?

Pros for year-round education

  • Students tend to forget a lot during the summer, and shorter vacations might increase retention rates.
  • Short breaks can provide time for students to receive enrichment education.
  • More students can be accommodated at one school through multi-tracking.
  • Students get bored during the long summer break
  • Scheduling family vacations will be easier to arrange.

 

Do Kids Do Better in Year Round School | amotherworld | www.amotherworld.com

Cons against year-round education

  • Studies have been inconclusive to its academic benefits.
  • Students  will forget information whether they are out of school for three weeks or 10.
  • Teachers will be performing four beginning of the year reviews instead of just one.
  • Summer programs such as camps suffer – experiences that children can benefit from.
  • Daycare may be difficult to find.
  • Student summer employment will be difficult.
  • Many schools are older and do not have air conditioning.
  • If the entire school district does not go year round, parents could have students at different schools on different schedules.
  • With multi-tracking, parents could have students at the same school on different schedules.

 

What do you think about year-round education?

Author

Maria Lianos-Carbone is the author of “Oh Baby! A Mom’s Self-Care Survival Guide for the First Year”, and publisher of amotherworld.com, a leading lifestyle blog for women.

17 Comments

  1. Nicole@ Kids Bedroom Furniture World Reply

    I’m totally against a year-round education, because I love summer as a kid, and it doesn’t interfere on what I become today. I think all things need a break and balance, and summer is the best break a student can get. I also don’t believe that student get bored during summer because it’s the best time of the year for a fun indoor and outdoor activities!

  2. Kelly Linhares Reply

    With academic results inconclusive, why mess with what has worked for ages? I LOVED summers off as a kid, especially in a country where summer is so coveted. And academically, I think I turned out okay.

    I don’t know too many people who can even attempt to take multiple 3 week vacations per year. Most save up for one big trip and perhaps a few weekend getaways if possible. With the majority of households bringing in 2 incomes, 4 long breaks throughout the year seems like more of a headache than anything else.

    Isn’t having their summer free also an incentive to attract new teachers? Every teacher I know appreciates those two months to regroup, relax, travel, pursue other interests etc. Should we be messing with a job that is already so under appreciated?

    I’m usually one ‘for’ change, but in this situation, it seems we’re adding unnecessary pressure in an already highly pressureized society… all for the sake of academic achievement. Let kids be kids.

    • Maria @amotherworld Reply

      Yes, definitely summer memories are ones to cherish… time for kids to go to camp, vacation and just hang out!

  3. Without having ever tried it I think our family would totally love year round school. We are very much creatures of habit. I think that having shorter breaks would mean we would all maintain the routine of school throughout the year.

    I don’t understand the argument that teachers would be performing “beginning of the year” assessments more than once. That seems unnecessary to me with shorter breaks. The year only begins once whether there is one break or many. Teachers don’t perform “assessments” now after holiday breaks and many schools are already out for several weeks at a time.

    • Maria @amotherworld Reply

      I can see how shorter breaks would work well. If the breaks are shorter, those assessments won’t be happening. I’m not sure I’d be ready to give up the whole summer – and neither would my kids – but I’d be open to hearing more about year-round school.

  4. If this is done while I’m still in school I will not go to school and thats that no summer vacation no school and I encourage all High school students to do the same if this year round school bullshit comes into effect

  5. I together with my buddies came going through the great information through your web page and also the sudden I got an awful feeling I had not thanked the website owner for people techniques. These men had been with this reason thrilled to learn all of them and have absolutely in effect surely been making the most of this stuff. Many appreciate your simply being indeed considerate and for choosing this style of brilliant tips a lot of individuals are really eager to understand about. My personal sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to sooner.

  6. summer is the best part of a child’s school why would someone take it away from us

  7. Why, thats like saying workers shouldn’t have any off days or vacations. Kids should have time with their family. Especially if your parents work in the military.

  8. carson byrne Reply

    i am a kid i know how you feel but are kids really that annoying that we have a website about kids going to summer school

  9. if we were to all to go to all year round school i would leave i would take a rocket ship and just leave into deep space

  10. Where didi you perhaps get your sources from? I need it for class! Thanks

  11. POV, you are reading this for your psych class on the creditability of this article

Write A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.